1. Home
  2. Policy impact
  3. England: bringing pupils’ experiences of health education into Parliament

England: bringing pupils’ experiences of health education into Parliament

Young people’s responses to the Health Behaviour in School-aged Children (HBSC) survey contributed to parliamentary scrutiny of school health education in England. The House of Commons Education Committee’s 2014–15 report, “Life lessons: PSHE and SRE in schools”, cited the survey when examining the quality of provision.

Personal, social, health and economic education, known as PSHE, covers topics relevant to pupils’ health and lives. The inquiry also considered sex and relationships education. Alongside evidence from inspectors, teachers and other organisations, the committee examined what young people themselves said about their lessons.

Pupils’ views in the inquiry

The committee reported that 47% of 11-, 13- and 15-year-olds in the 2014 HBSC survey in England felt that sex and relationships issues were very well covered in PSHE. It also noted that 42% thought these lessons were as challenging as other school lessons.

These findings added pupils’ experiences to wider concerns about teaching quality. In its conclusions, the committee said that professional assessments of weaknesses matched young people’s views, and recommended government action to encourage schools to improve provision.

A wider use of the same evidence

The survey also supported separate analysis by the University of Hertfordshire and the PSHE Association. Drawing on responses from 5,335 pupils, their briefing examined relationships between perceptions of PSHE and experiences of school.

Pupils who felt relevant topics were covered well were more likely to report positive relationships and a sense of belonging, and less likely to report involvement in bullying. These were associations, rather than proof that lessons caused the differences, but they offered further questions for research and practice.

Together, these uses show how a school survey can contribute both to formal policy scrutiny and to professional discussion. The parliamentary record provides a clear example of HBSC evidence being considered in recommendations; it does not, on its own, establish that the study caused subsequent changes in law or classroom practice.

Sources

Explore more policy impact examples